Free homeowner tool

Rent it or sell it?

Compare a sale today with renting your home for a few years and selling later. Test the cash flow, mortgage payoff, and future sale assumptions behind each path.

Your assumptions

Sale today

Keep as a rental

Future outlook

This models the property only. It assumes the current mortgage continues, with a fixed rate and regular principal-and-interest payments. Enter taxes and insurance in operating costs even if escrowed, and do not count them twice.

Comparison snapshot

Sell today · estimated cash

$220,000

Rent, then sell · today’s dollars

$259,402

At these assumptions, the modeled rental path is $39,402 higher in today’s dollars. This is a scenario comparison, not a recommendation.

Sale price today$500,000
Sale today after selling costs and payoffs$220,000
First-year rental cash flow$661
Total rental cash flow over hold$7,147
Projected future sale price$552,040
Mortgage balance at future sale$204,809
Future sale after costs and payoffs$314,109
Upfront rent-ready costs-$5,000
Rent-then-sell total · future dollars$316,256

The headline rental amount discounts annual cash flow and future sale proceeds at 4% per year, then subtracts today’s rent-ready costs. Future dollars and today’s dollars are shown separately.

Choose your print format

Anyone with the link can view these inputs. Do not include private client details.

Illustrative, pre-tax property comparison. It excludes income and capital-gains taxes, depreciation and recapture, reinvestment returns on sale proceeds, alternative housing costs, and unexpected repairs. Confirm mortgage payoff, local rents, taxes, and transaction costs before deciding.

Rental path year by year

Cash flow is after vacancy, operating costs, and principal and interest. The mortgage balance falls as payments reduce principal.

YearRent after vacancyOperating costsLoan paymentsCash flowMortgage balance
1$29,640$10,800$18,179$661$241,669
2$30,233$11,016$18,179$1,037$232,998
3$30,837$11,236$18,179$1,422$223,975
4$31,454$11,461$18,179$1,814$214,583
5$32,083$11,690$18,179$2,214$204,809

How to read the comparison

Compare two paths to the same point

Selling today gives estimated cash after selling costs and current payoffs. The rental path collects cash flow each year and assumes a sale at the end of your chosen hold period. The future sale subtracts selling costs and the remaining mortgage balance.

Separate future dollars from today’s dollars

Cash received years from now is not the same as cash available today. The discount rate converts each year’s modeled rental cash flow and the eventual sale into today’s dollars. Try several rates because the result can change substantially.

Model the mortgage carefully

The loan payment is calculated from today’s balance, rate, and remaining term. Principal paydown lowers the balance at a future sale. Property tax and insurance belong in operating costs; if your mortgage payment includes escrow, enter only principal and interest through the loan fields.

Stress-test the rental

Check local rent and likely vacancy. Operating costs should include taxes, insurance, maintenance, major repair reserves, management, utilities, and HOA charges. Test lower rent, higher costs, and little or no appreciation before leaning on a favorable result.

Understand the exclusions

The model does not estimate taxes. Renting a former primary residence can affect future sale taxation, including depreciation rules. It also does not model how you might invest the cash from an immediate sale or the cost of your next home. Discuss those with qualified professionals.

Refine each side

Use the seller net sheet for contract-specific closing details and the rental deal screen for a fuller breakdown of operating costs. This comparison is a decision screen; neither path is guaranteed to perform as modeled.

For background on loan paydown and sale taxes, see the CFPB mortgage guide and IRS Publication 523.

Explore each path with local context

An agent can help check a realistic sale price and local rent. A property manager can test operating costs, and a lender or tax professional can review financing and tax questions.